Skip to main content
ManagedFunds.nz

Fund-vs-fund · Australasian Equities

Clarity Trans-Tasman Value FundvsSmart NZ Mid Cap ETF

Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund (fund size NZ$154.5 million at 30 September 2026, total fund charges 1.06% for the year to 31 March 2026) is an Australasian equities managed fund and Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF (fund size NZ$125.3 million at 30 September 2026, total fund charges 0.60% for the year to 31 March 2026) is an Australasian equities ETF, per the fund updates for Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund and Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF filed on FMA Disclose; Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund's 1-year return after fees and tax was 13.87% for the year to 31 March 2026, per its quarterly fund update filed on FMA Disclose.

How much do these two overlap?

They hold 20 of the same securities. If you held both, roughly 27.5% of your money would be in the same companies — so the diversification you get from holding the pair is smaller than holding two funds suggests.

27.5%
Shared holdingClarity Trans-TasmanSmart NZMin weight
Mercury NZNZX: MCY ↗2.36%10.64%2.36%
Genesis EnergyNZX: GNE ↗2.24%3.58%2.24%
ANZ Group Holdings LtdNZX: ANZ ↗5.88%2.20%2.20%
FREIGHTWAYSNZX: FRW ↗2.08%4.94%2.08%
Summerset GroupNZX: SUM ↗1.93%4.04%1.93%
TowerNZX: TWR ↗2.23%1.50%1.50%
Argosy PropertyNZX: ARG ↗1.43%1.98%1.43%
Channel Infrastructure NZNZX: CHI ↗1.37%3.29%1.37%
Vista Group InternationalNZX: VGL ↗1.36%1.48%1.36%
Ryman HealthcareNZX: RYM ↗1.35%3.91%1.35%

Min weight is the smaller of the two weightings — if you hold both funds, that is the floor of your exposure to that position. Direct holdings only: anything either fund holds through an underlying fund or ETF is not counted, so the real overlap can only be higher. From each fund's FMA Disclose full portfolio filing.

NZX links open the listed company's page on NZXplorer.co.nz, shown only where the holding has a verified NZX ticker. NZXplorer is a sister site, run by the same publisher as ManagedFundsNZ. We receive no fee for this link, and it is not a recommendation.

Where you can buy these

Platform availability confirmed within the last 180 days. This is a statement of availability, not a recommendation — ManagedFundsNZ is not a Financial Advice Provider. Check the current PDS before investing.

Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund

No platform availability confirmed. Usually means it is bought directly from the manager — check their site.

Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF

Why these two differ

Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF and Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund are both Australasian equities portfolios with nearly identical growth-asset allocations (98.46% versus 98.31%), but they differ materially in fee structure, risk profile, and five-year performance.

Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF charges 0.6% annually and carries a risk indicator of 5, reflecting its focus on New Zealand mid-cap companies. Its five-year return was –0.25%. Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund charges 1.06% annually and carries a risk indicator of 4, suggesting lower volatility. Its five-year return was 5.78%. The 46-basis-point fee difference compounds significantly over time; the performance gap of 6.03 percentage points over five years suggests different market positioning, though Clarity's lower risk indicator indicates its value strategy may have exposed the fund to different volatility patterns than Smart's mid-cap tilt.

Portfolio construction reflects these strategies: Smart's top five holdings are dominated by New Zealand utilities and infrastructure (Mercury, Chorus, Port of Tauranga), with 33.84% concentrated in those five names. Clarity's top five span mining, banking, and energy across Australia and New Zealand (BHP, ANZ, NAB, Meridian, Infratil), with 24.38% concentration, suggesting broader diversification.

Both funds manage similar assets (approximately $125–133 million) and are available within your KiwiSaver scheme account options. Verify the latest Product Disclosure Statement and Quarterly Fund Update on the FMA Disclose website before making any investment decision.

Comparison generated 2026-11-15 from each fund's FMA Disclose QFU facts as at that date. If the underlying facts change, this narrative is withheld until it is regenerated — the tables on this page always reflect the current data.

What's different at a glance

  • Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF is 0.46 percentage points lower on total fund charges (0.60% vs 1.06%, year to 31 March 2026).
  • Both are New Zealand PIE funds — investor tax is capped at the Prescribed Investor Rate (PIR), maximum 28%.

Where each fund sits in its cohort

Percentile rank vs all 57 Australasian equities funds we've matched on Sorted Smart Investor. Mechanical only — no opinion, no forward-looking view.

The fees and sizes in this panel are Sorted's annual fund charge and fund size for every fund, so each is ranked on the same measure. The table below shows each fund's own quarterly fund update figure where we hold one, which can differ.

Annual fund charge (Sorted)

Lower is better

Clarity

1.06%

Upper half of cohort

Smartshares

0.60%

Lower half of cohort

5-year return p.a.

Past performance — not a predictor

Clarity

5.78%

Top 23% over 5 years

Smartshares

-0.25%

Lower half over 5 years

Fund size (Sorted)

Larger = more stable, lower close-risk

Clarity

NZ$133m

Upper half by size

Smartshares

NZ$125m

Upper half by size

MetricClaritySmartsharesLower / higher is
Fund charges1.06%Total fund charges, year to 31 March 20260.60%Total fund charges, year to 31 March 2026Lower is better
Risk indicator (1–7)45Higher = more volatility
5-year return p.a.5.78%-0.25%Higher is better
(past not future)
Fund sizeNZ$154mTotal value of the fund at 30 September 2026NZ$125mTotal value of the fund at 30 September 2026Larger = more stable, lower close-risk
Growth / income split98% / 2%98% / 2%More growth = higher long-run return + volatility
NZ tax structurePIE (PIR-capped)PIE (PIR-capped)PIE = simpler. FIF = annual return.
Currency hedging——Hedged smooths NZD/foreign FX moves at a small cost.
Responsible investment screeningNoNoSpecific exclusions live in each fund's SIPO.
Available viaDirectDirectPlatforms accepting retail subscriptions.

What each fund says it does

Clarity

Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund

The Fund will provide actively managed exposure to New Zealand and Australian equities. The Fund aims to generate a better return than the benchmark over the medium to long term. It employs a value investing strategy, typically favouring companies which offer higher earnings yields. We intend for the Fund to make quarterly income distributions.
Full Clarity Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund profile →

Smartshares

Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF

The Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF is designed to track the return (before tax, fees and other expenses) of the S&P/NZX MidCap Index. The Index is comprised of companies listed on the NZX that are included in the S&P/NZX 50 Index but are not included in the S&P/NZX 10 Index.
Full Smartshares Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF profile →

Common questions

What's the difference between the Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund and the Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF?
Both are Australasian equities funds available to NZ retail investors. Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF is 0.46 percentage points lower on total fund charges (0.60% vs 1.06%, year to 31 March 2026).
Which fund has lower fees, Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund or Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF?
Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF has the lower total fund charges (0.60% vs 1.06%, year to 31 March 2026). Sources: for Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund, the fund's quarterly fund update for the quarter ended 30 September 2026, filed on FMA Disclose; for Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF, the fund's quarterly fund update for the quarter ended 30 September 2026, filed on FMA Disclose.
How do the 5-year returns compare?
Clarity Trans-Tasman Value Fund's 5-year return p.a. is 5.78% and Smart NZ Mid Cap ETF's is -0.25% (after fees, before tax). Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns.
Are both funds PIE-taxed in NZ?
Yes. Both are NZ Portfolio Investment Entities (PIEs). Investor tax on the fund's income is capped at the Prescribed Investor Rate (PIR), maximum 28%.
Where can I read the official documents for these funds?
Both funds publish their Product Disclosure Statement (PDS), Statement of Investment Policy (SIPO) and Quarterly Fund Update (QFU) on the FMA Disclose register at disclose-register.companiesoffice.govt.nz. Always read the current PDS before investing.
FinanceAdvisers.co.nz logo
Not sure which fund is right for you?
Find a financial adviser on FinanceAdvisers.co.nz
Browse NZ-licensed financial advice providers and search by speciality, location and review.
→
Important: This comparison is general information only — not personalised financial advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns. The right fund for you depends on your personal circumstances. Read each fund's Product Disclosure Statement and consider speaking to a licensed financial adviser.